|LoFi version for PDAs||Help Search Members Calendar|
|Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )||Resend Validation Email|
Posted: Jul 4 2009, 12:50 PM
Group: Power Member
Joined: 4-December 05
Positive Feedback: 60.32%
Feedback Score: -43
What is Moral Folk Theory?
The attempt to seek knowledge presupposes that the world unfolds in a systematic pattern and that we can gain knowledge of that unfolding. Cognitive science identifies several ideas that seem to come naturally to us and labels such ideas as “Folk Theories”.
The Folk Theory of the Intelligibility of the World
The world makes systematic sense, and we can gain knowledge of it.
The Folk Theory of General Kinds
Every particular thing is a kind of thing.
The Folk Theory of Essences
Every entity has an “essence” or “nature,” that is, a collection of properties that makes it the kind of thing it is and that is the causal source of its natural behavior.
The consequences of the two theories of kinds and essences are:
The Foundational Assumption of Metaphysics
Kinds exist and are defined by essences.
We may not want our friends to know this fact but we are all metaphysicians. We, in fact, assume that things have a nature thereby we are led by the metaphysical impulse to seek knowledge at various levels of reality.
Cognitive science has uncovered these ideas they have labeled as Folk Theories. Such theories when compared to sophisticated philosophical theories are like comparing mountain music with classical music. Such theories seem to come naturally to human consciousness.
What is Moral Law Folk Theory?
Moral Law Folk Theory, encoded within objectivist philosophy, holds “that there are absolute moral laws, that they can be discovered by reason, and that they can be applied directly and objectively to real situations.”
SGCS (Second Generation Cognitive Science) claims and I agree that “it is morally irresponsible to think and act as though we possess a universal, disembodied reason that generates absolute rules, decision-making procedures, and universal or categorical laws by which we can tell right from wrong in any situation we encounter.”
Folk Theories are based upon the book by George Lakoff and Mark Johnson Philosophy in the Flesh
Moral Law Folk Theory is based upon the book by Mark Johnson Moral Imagination
Posted: Jul 5 2009, 11:39 PM
Joined: 17-June 09
Positive Feedback: 50%
Feedback Score: 0
You appear to be misstating this. Cognitive science has hardly uncovered these ideas. Cognitive science is a beneficiary of what is has recognised and labelled, but it has hardly uncovered it.
Science, through the work of Gilbert, and Bacon and Galileo and the like established an approach that embraced methodological naturalism and a presumption that the world could be understood. So, two points of perceived reality run counter to what you appear to be trying to say:
1. Cognitive science did not uncover this idea. It was plainly displayed, discussed and promoted by scientists.
2. Demeaning this practical approach as unsophisticated suggests a complete failure to comprehend the nature of this approach.